R9 295x2 ve GTX 1080 Karşılaştırması

Bu yazı daha önce açılmış gereksiz konu ve Nvidia fanlarına hitaben yazılmıştır. Yazı tamamen bana aittir.

''Bu devirde Nvidia'dan şaşmayacaksın, parasını tamamen hakediyor. Üstüne o güzelim logoyu yapıştırıyorsun, yeşil yeşil. GTX 1080 diyorum, başka bir şey demiyorum. RX 480 anca 1060 ile kapışır. R9 295x2'yi bile geçiyor. Ondan sonra Titan X ve Z de var. Tabi bunları almak için para dökmen lazım.''

Bi kere RX 480'nin fiyatı 1080 ile aynı da mı, sen gidiyorsun 1080 ile karşılaştırıyorsun? AMD daha üst seviye kart çıkartmadı diye, fiyat farkını göze almayıp son serinin en üst seviye kartlarını mı karşılaştırıyorsun? RX 480, kendisiyle aynı fiyata sahip olan 1060'ı DX 12'de tokatlıyor.

Gelelim R9 295x2'ye. Ya kardeşim gelmişsin buraya R9 295x2'yi 2 nesil sonraki kartlarla karşılaştırıyorsun. R9 serisi ile 7xx serisi birbirine denktir. Git Titan Z, Black ile felan karşılaştır. Sonra gel bakalım kim kimi tokatlamış. Kaldı ki R9 295x2 bazı oyunlarda 1080'i geçiyor, bazı oyunlarda eşit, bazılarında ise 5-6 FPS daha az veriyor.

R9 295x2 1800 TL.
GTX 1080 3200-3500 TL.

Aradaki tek fark güç tüketimi. Sen yeni bir sistem toplarken PSU'ya daha fazla para verecen diye, bazı oyunlarda 5-6 FPS fazla alacan diye 1700 TL fazla mı para vericeksin?

Konu açılmışken ne kadar başlıktan uzaklaşsakta, gelin sizinle AMD ve Nvidia'nın, R9 ve 7xx'de çıkartmış olduğu kartları performans açısından kıyaslayalım.

R9 270X vs GTX 760. Üstteki 270X, alttaki 760.

Metro: Last Light - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
41.6
45.3
Metro: Last Light - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
50.4
54.6
Company of Heroes 2 - 1920x1080 - Maximum Quality + Med. AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
37.5
31.7
Company of Heroes 2 - 1920x1080 - High Quality + Low AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
60.2
45.9
Company of Heroes 2 - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - Maximum Quality + Med. AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
25.2
20.3
Company of Heroes 2 - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - High Quality + Low AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
42.8
32.1
Bioshock Infinite - 1920x1080 - Ultra Quality + DDoF
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
55.1
71.2
Bioshock Infinite - 1920x1080 - Ultra Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
75
87.2
Battlefield 4 - 1920x1080 - Ultra Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
43.1
47.1
Battlefield 4 - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
68.8
70.2
Crysis 3 - 1920x1080 - High Quality + FXAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
46.5
59.5
Crysis 3 - 1920x1080 - Medium Quality + FXAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
73.3
85.9
Crysis: Warhead - 1920x1080 - Enthusiast Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
48.4
50.3
Crysis: Warhead - 1920x1080 - E Shaders/G Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
81
85
Crysis: Warhead - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - Enthusiast Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
35.6
37.2
Crysis: Warhead - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - E Shaders/G Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
57.7
54.1
Total War: Rome 2 - 1920x1080 - Extreme Quality + Med. Shadows
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
41.9
40.6
Total War: Rome 2 - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality + Med. Shadows
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
74.2
69.9
Thief - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
41.4
41.8
Thief - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
50.5
50
Thief - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
24.4
26.9
Thief - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
31.4
33
GRID 2 - 1920x1080 - Maximum Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
71.5
70.5
GRID 2 - 1920x1080 - High Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
155.6
161

Görüldüğü üzere eşit.

R9 280X vs GTX 770. Üsttekiler 280X.

Metro: Last Light - 2560x1440 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
44
42.1
Metro: Last Light - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
54.4
55.7
Metro: Last Light - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
66
64.8
Company of Heroes 2 - 3840x2160 - Low Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
30.3
24.4
Company of Heroes 2 - 2560x1440 - Maximum Quality + Med. AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
30
26.3
Company of Heroes 2 - 1920x1080 - Maximum Quality + Med. AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
45.1
39.8
Company of Heroes 2 - 1920x1080 - High Quality + Low AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
67.7
56.9
Company of Heroes 2 - Min. Frame Rate - 3840x2160 - Low Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
18.4
15.6
Company of Heroes 2 - Min. Frame Rate - 2560x1440 - Maximum Quality + Med. AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
20
16.6
Company of Heroes 2 - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - Maximum Quality + Med. AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
31.3
25.7
Company of Heroes 2 - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - High Quality + Low AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
49.4
39.1
Bioshock Infinite - 2560x1440 - Ultra Quality + DDoF
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
47.2
55.6
Bioshock Infinite - 1920x1080 - Ultra Quality + DDoF
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
73.9
86.9
Bioshock Infinite - 1920x1080 - Ultra Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
98.8
107.7
Battlefield 4 - 2560x1440 - Ultra Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
36
37.4
Battlefield 4 - 1920x1080 - Ultra Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
54.5
57
Battlefield 4 - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
83.8
86.1
Crysis 3 - 3840x2160 - Low Quality + FXAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
34.4
36.6
Crysis 3 - 2560x1440 - High Quality + FXAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
41.5
46.9
Crysis 3 - 1920x1080 - High Quality + FXAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
61.2
71.6
Crysis 3 - 1920x1080 - Medium Quality + FXAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
94.2
101.6
Crysis: Warhead - 3840x2160 - Gamer Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
37.9
32.5
Crysis: Warhead - 2560x1440 - Enthusiast Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
41.7
36.4
Crysis: Warhead - 1920x1080 - Enthusiast Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
62.5
57.8
Crysis: Warhead - 1920x1080 - E Shaders/G Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
106.5
93.3
Crysis: Warhead - Min. Frame Rate - 3840x2160 - Gamer Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
28.2
21.7
Crysis: Warhead - Min. Frame Rate - 2560x1440 - Enthusiast Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
30.9
26.3
Crysis: Warhead - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - Enthusiast Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
46.9
41.7
Crysis: Warhead - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - E Shaders/G Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
78.5
62.4
Total War: Rome 2 - 3840x2160 - Very High Quality + Med. Shadows
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
30.9
30.1
Total War: Rome 2 - 2560x1440 - Extreme Quality + Med. Shadows
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
33.8
31.4
Total War: Rome 2 - 1920x1080 - Extreme Quality + Med. Shadows
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
53.1
50.4
Total War: Rome 2 - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality + Med. Shadows
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
93.3
88
Thief - 2560x1440 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
36.1
33.3
Thief - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
52.4
51.1
Thief - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
63.5
60.7
Thief - Min. Frame Rate - 2560x1440 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
29.4
20.9
Thief - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
39.2
36.9
Thief - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
45.7
40.9
GRID 2 - 3840x2160 - Maximum Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
38.7
33.4
GRID 2 - 2560x1440 - Maximum Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
66.9
63.4
GRID 2 - 1920x1080 - Maximum Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
91.7
88.7
GRID 2 - 1920x1080 - High Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
177.2
197.5

280X biraz farkla önde.

R9 290X vs GTX 780. Üsttekiler R9 290X.

Metro: Last Light - 3840x2160 - Medium Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
49.8
43.2
Metro: Last Light - 2560x1440 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
59.5
55.5
Metro: Last Light - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
76
65.9
Metro: Last Light - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
86.8
79.3
Company of Heroes 2 - 3840x2160 - Low Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
40.9
29.9
Company of Heroes 2 - 2560x1440 - Maximum Quality + Med. AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
42.3
33.2
Company of Heroes 2 - 1920x1080 - Maximum Quality + Med. AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
62.6
50.7
Company of Heroes 2 - 1920x1080 - High Quality + Low AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
74.6
72.7
Company of Heroes 2 - Min. Frame Rate - 3840x2160 - Low Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
28.2
20
Company of Heroes 2 - Min. Frame Rate - 2560x1440 - Maximum Quality + Med. AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
28.8
22.5
Company of Heroes 2 - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - Maximum Quality + Med. AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
44
34
Company of Heroes 2 - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - High Quality + Low AA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
51.5
44.4
Bioshock Infinite - 3840x2160 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
50.1
42.1
Bioshock Infinite - 2560x1440 - Ultra Quality + DDoF
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
62
67.7
Bioshock Infinite - 1920x1080 - Ultra Quality + DDoF
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
94.9
103.7
Bioshock Infinite - 1920x1080 - Ultra Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
130
124.8
Battlefield 4 - 3840x2160 - Medium Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
67.5
49.4
Battlefield 4 - 2560x1440 - Ultra Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
49
44.5
Battlefield 4 - 1920x1080 - Ultra Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
72.7
67.6
Battlefield 4 - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
108.9
99.1
Crysis 3 - 3840x2160 - Low Quality + FXAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
42.8
39.4
Crysis 3 - 2560x1440 - High Quality + FXAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
52.9
51.2
Crysis 3 - 1920x1080 - High Quality + FXAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
79.6
79.6
Crysis 3 - 1920x1080 - Medium Quality + FXAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
115.7
112.2
Crysis: Warhead - 3840x2160 - Gamer Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
47.4
38.7
Crysis: Warhead - 2560x1440 - Enthusiast Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
52.5
45.5
Crysis: Warhead - 1920x1080 - Enthusiast Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
83.5
70.1
Crysis: Warhead - 1920x1080 - E Shaders/G Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
128.3
124.1
Crysis: Warhead - Min. Frame Rate - 3840x2160 - Gamer Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
38
28.7
Crysis: Warhead - Min. Frame Rate - 2560x1440 - Enthusiast Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
38.6
35.9
Crysis: Warhead - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - Enthusiast Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
66.3
55.4
Crysis: Warhead - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - E Shaders/G Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
80.9
79.6
Total War: Rome 2 - 3840x2160 - Very High Quality + Med. Shadows
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
43.3
33.8
Total War: Rome 2 - 2560x1440 - Extreme Quality + Med. Shadows
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
46.5
38.8
Total War: Rome 2 - 1920x1080 - Extreme Quality + Med. Shadows
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
72.6
61.2
Total War: Rome 2 - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality + Med. Shadows
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
117.2
103.4
Thief - 3840x2160 - Very High Quality, No SSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
40
33.7
Thief - 2560x1440 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
47.4
42
Thief - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
66.7
61.2
Thief - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
74.3
71.6
Thief - Min. Frame Rate - 3840x2160 - Very High Quality, No SSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
32
22.4
Thief - Min. Frame Rate - 2560x1440 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
37.5
31.1
Thief - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - Very High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
48.1
45.5
Thief - Min. Frame Rate - 1920x1080 - High Quality
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
48.3
54.7
GRID 2 - 3840x2160 - Maximum Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
50.6
39.6
GRID 2 - 2560x1440 - Maximum Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
85.7
73.8
GRID 2 - 1920x1080 - Maximum Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
112.9
102.7
GRID 2 - 1920x1080 - High Quality + 4x MSAA
Frames per Second - Higher is Better
184.5
200.2

Bu sefer bariz 290X yenmiş.

''R9 290X, 780 Ti'ı yenemiyor.''

Sen R9 290X'ı ancak 780 ile karşılaştırabilirsin. AMD 780 Ti'a rakip bir kart çıkartmadı. Çıkartmadı değil, çıkartmadı. Kaldıki 780 Ti'ın o zamanki fiyatlarını bilen bilir. Alınmaya değer bir kart değildi. R9 290X ile 780 Ti arasında fazla fark yok.

Bunları okuduktan sonra, bu durumda, sen nasıl Nvidia'yı savunursun?

AMD fanı değilim ama bu tür insanlar sinirimi bozuyor.

Testler AnandTech sitesine aittir, güvenilirdir. Hiç bozmadan yapıştırdım, bench>GPU 2014'e girip bizzat kontrol edebilirsiniz. İyi günler, kolay gelsin.

RX 480 ile GTX 1080 modelini karşılaştırmak fanboylukla açıklanamaz, bunun adı cahillik ve bilgisizlik olur. R9 295X modeline gelirsek eğer GTX 1070 modeli arasında 500-700 TL civarları fiyat farkı olmadığı sürece mantıklı tercih GTX 1070 almaktır. Bu site de Nvidia fanboylukları yok sadece AMD fanboyları da var buna bir açıklık getirmek lazım ama Nvidia fanboyluğu yapanların sayısının çok daha fazla olduğu kesin.

BERWAR dedi:

RX 480 ile GTX 1080 modelini karşılaştırmak fanboylukla açıklanamaz, bunun adı cahillik ve bilgisizlik olur.

Genişletmek için tıkla...

RolandGarros dedi:

RX 480 anca 1060 ile kapışır. R9 295x2'yi bile geçiyor.

Genişletmek için tıkla...

Buradaki yazıya göre, bunu diyen kahramanımızın bilgisi yerinde. Sadece propaganda amaçlı bunu söylemiş. İki firmanın da son nesil son seviye GPU'larını göz önüne almış.
Bu fanboyluktur.

R9 295X2 geçiyor hangi kart için söylüyor ve kimden bahsediyorsun?